Justin Waldrop
Mar 6, 2023

From Control to Collaboration: The Case for Autonomy

Autonomy in the workplace is a crucial component of employee motivation and performance. Numerous studies, including those by Pink, Deci and Ryan, Gagné and Deci, Hackman and Oldham, and Baard, Deci, and Ryan, have shown that autonomy is positively related to employee well-being, job satisfaction, and performance. Yet, many companies fail to enable autonomy in the workplace, despite the evidence that they should. This blog post will explore the reasons behind this and offer solutions to help companies embrace autonomy and its benefits.

Companies are failing to enable autonomy in the workplace.

This is a major problem, as autonomy is crucial to employee motivation and performance. Without autonomy, employees may feel micromanaged, demotivated, and disengaged. This can lead to decreased productivity, job satisfaction, and well-being. Ultimately, companies that fail to enable autonomy in the workplace may struggle to retain top talent and maintain a competitive edge.

To embrace autonomy in the workplace, companies need to shift their management philosophy and adopt a culture of trust and risk-taking.

Control-oriented management styles are a major reason companies fail to enable autonomy in the workplace. Managers may believe they must maintain control over employees to ensure productivity and efficiency. However, this can lead to micromanagement and restricted autonomy. To solve this, managers should focus on empowering their employees by delegating decision-making power and allowing them to take ownership of their work.

Fear of failure is another reason companies may be reluctant to enable autonomy in the workplace. Some companies may be risk-averse and fear that giving employees too much autonomy will lead to mistakes and failure. However, failure is often a necessary step on the road to success. Companies should embrace failure as a learning opportunity and encourage employees to take calculated risks.

Lack of trust is a major barrier to autonomy in the workplace. If a company does not trust its employees to make decisions and take responsibility for their work, it may be less likely to provide autonomy. Companies should communicate clearly and effectively with their employees to build trust, provide them with the necessary resources and support, and recognize and reward their successes.

Traditional hierarchical structures can limit autonomy for employees lower down in the organization. To enable autonomy, companies should flatten their hierarchies and empower employees at all levels to make decisions and take ownership of their work. This can lead to a more agile and responsive organization.

Finally, companies may fail to enable autonomy in the workplace due to a lack of understanding of its benefits. To educate companies on the benefits of autonomy, managers should be provided with training and resources to empower their employees and enable autonomy. This can lead to a more engaged and motivated workforce.


Enabling autonomy in the workplace is crucial for employee motivation, satisfaction, and performance. Companies that fail to enable autonomy may struggle to retain top talent and maintain a competitive edge. By shifting their management philosophy and adopting a culture of trust and risk-taking, companies can embrace autonomy and reap its benefits.

We Can Help!

If you’re looking to improve efficiencies, reduce redundancies, and increase your social impact, we’re here to help. Our team of experts can work with you to develop a tailored solution that meets your unique needs and helps you achieve your goals.

Breaking the Filter Bubble

How Nonprofits Can Thrive on Social Media Nonprofits face unique challenges in leveraging social media for organic community building. The algorithms that power platforms like Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter have transformed the way content is surfaced to users,...

6 Powerful Reasons Why Blogging Remains Essential

In today's fast-paced digital landscape, nonprofits and purpose-driven organizations face an ongoing challenge to capture and maintain their audience's attention. While video and social media often steal the limelight with their flashy, eye-catching content, one...

5 Ways Social Proof Can Boost Nonprofits and Purpose-Driven Businesses

Social proof is a psychological phenomenon where people rely on the actions and opinions of others to make decisions, especially in uncertain situations. It is a powerful marketing tool that can help nonprofits and purpose-driven businesses scale their impact. This...

How to Secure Funding in Anticipation of a Recession

Nonprofit leaders' top concern has become a lack of resources, surpassing donor acquisition. In this post, we'll examine nonprofits' challenges in securing funding and provide solutions to help them navigate this difficult time.   The Changing Landscape of Donor...

Top 5 Nonprofit Website Mistakes

As a nonprofit, your website is critical for reaching your target audience and achieving your mission. However, it's easy to make mistakes that can undermine the effectiveness of your site and detract from your overall message. In this article, we'll explore the top...